ALP Legal Alert

Busenvi Enterprise Ltd v Makindye Ssabagabo Municipal Council

By ALP Advocate
on
October 1, 2022

High Court holds that referral of a dispute to arbitration requires evidence by way of a formal application and cannot be entertained in the form of a preliminary objection on the point of law without such evidence.

Evidentiary proof of agreement to arbitrate: Busenvi Enterprise Ltd v Makindye Ssabagabo Municipal Council, Civil Suit No 400/2019

In a suit involving a road construction, the Plaintiff sought against the Defendant remedies that included, among others, specific performance, damages, interest, and costs. When the suit came up for hearing, the Defendant raised a preliminary objection that the matter be referred to arbitration in light of the provisions of the General Conditions of Contract, and sections 5 and 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.

In a decision issued on July 1, 2022, the trial judge rejected the preliminary objection raised. Nambayo, J. ruled that evidentiary proof is necessary for a determination to refer the matter to arbitration, holding that section 5 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act requires a party to “apply to court”. The evidentiary proof requires there be "a formal application” for a court to determine, as a matter of law, that the matter be referred to arbitration. A preliminary objection on a point of law will not suffice. The judge ordered the matter proceed for hearing and left it to the Defendant to file a formal application on referral to arbitration.

The ruling in the matter underscores the principle that there must be an application in terms of section 5 of the Act, which serves as a basis of a hearing conducted by a court to ascertain voidness, inoperativeness, and incapability of performance of an arbitration agreement, or the absence of an arbitrable dispute. A court must ascertain the prima facie existence of an arbitration agreement and arbitrable dispute. This requires evidence before the court.


Download this Legal Alert as a PDF file here

Disclaimer

No information contained in this alert should be construed as legal advice from ALP East Africa or ALP Advocates or the individual authors, nor is it intended to be a substitute for legal counsel on any subject matter.

For additional information in relation to this alert, please contact the following:

  • Lastone Balyainho Gulume

         Practice Director/Head, Dispute Resolution Department

       lgulume@alp-ea.com

  • Henry Onoria

        Head, Law Consulting & Knowledge Department

       honoria@alp-ea.com